Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Havakuk's avatar

Terrific, highly original reflections! Thank you.

Await following instalments with interest.

Expand full comment
Chris Bateman's avatar

Well of all the things I thought I was going to be up to today, reading a reflection on the relationship between Noah and lockdown was not among them! 😂 I may need to reflect on this one a little more before I can adequately comment, and I very much look forward to your piece on Babel, which is my favourite section of Genesis.

On the rainbow, sex, and gender - you bring this up as a passing irony. I want to engage briefly on this point, although as usual it will probably not end up brief at all.

It has come to pass that this culture war now operates primarily in the divide between Christianity (which has theological connections to the division of the sexes, as you allude to here) and the genderqueer crowd. But this is not in fact how this cultural battlefront was opened up - historically, this began as an internecine struggle *within* the Rainbow Alliance, specifically between trans activists (themselves only a part of the trans community) and lesbian feminists. I won't go into the sordid details of this part of the history, although I have followed it more-or-less from the beginning, and it broke my heart to watch it happen.

The ironic outcome of the transition to this becoming a Christian cultural battlefront (which it absolutely was not in the first instance) is that this has now led to closer bonds between the lesbian feminists (or gender-critical feminists - which is a wider label) and the Christian community. Because perhaps for the first time, these diverse camps have something in common; their ways of living are challenged and undermined by the trans activists, and they are willing to work together to defend what woman had previously fought long and hard to secure.

To say that this entire situation is a grotesque mess is an understatement. It is also especially galling to me, as someone who sees the mission of Christianity in the chaos of authentic diversity (and not the imperial colonialism of 'inclusion', which is inherently opposed to diversity). On a path not taken, the trans community at large could have been reconciled with and had good relations with the Christian community, since in the first instance they shared in common a idealised conception of gender (albeit, as Illich taught me, not at all the conception of gender they started out with). The primary reason it did not go this way in my view is that the trans activist movement came together as a youth movement in the urban context of the United States, where opposing Christianity/Republicans/the Red Team, is an absolute tribal requirement. In a sense, part of the appeal of the path taken by the trans activists was precisely to enrage certain Christian neighbours. And it absolutely did not have to be this way.

I could say more on this, but I fear this is as large a tangent as I should allow under the circumstances.

Looking forward to your reflection on Babel!

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts